Carrie Underwood nagradna dominacija: Kompletna lista pobjeda (do 2024)
Carrie Underwood nije samo najnagrađenija American Idol alumna — ona je country glazbena moć s trofejnim ormarom koji obuhvaća sve veće ceremonije. Evo raspodjele do 2024.
Grammy Awards (8 pobjeda, 16 nominacija)
- 2006: Best New Artist
- 2006: Best Female Country Vocal Performance — "Jesus, Take the Wheel"
- 2007: Best Country Album — Some Hearts
- 2008: Best Female Country Vocal Performance — "Before He Cheats"
- 2008: Best Country Song — "Before He Cheats"
- 2009: Best Female Country Vocal Performance — "Last Name"
- 2013: Best Country Solo Performance — "Blown Away"
- 2015: Best Country Solo Performance — "Something in the Water"
CMA Awards (12 pobjeda)
- 2005: Horizon Award, Female Vocalist of the Year
- 2006: Female Vocalist, Music Video of the Year — "Jesus, Take the Wheel"
- 2007: Female Vocalist, Album of the Year — Some Hearts
- 2008: Female Vocalist, Song of the Year — "Before He Cheats," Music Video — "Before He Cheats"
- 2009: Album of the Year — Play On
- 2010, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2018, 2019: Female Vocalist of the Year (rekord 8×)
- 2013: Album of the Year — Blown Away
- 2015: Pinnacle Award
- 2019: Entertainer of the Year
ACM Awards (16 pobjeda)
- 2006: Top New Female Vocalist, Top Female Vocalist, Song of the Year — "Jesus, Take the Wheel," Single Record of the Year — "Jesus, Take the Wheel"
- 2007, 2008, 2009, 2011, 2012, 2015, 2016, 2019: Top Female Vocalist (8×)
- 2008: Song of the Year — "Before He Cheats," Single Record of the Year — "Before He Cheats"
- 2009: Album of the Year — Play On
Ostale veće nagrade
- American Music Awards: 17 pobjeda (Favorite Female Country Artist 12×, Favorite Country Album 6×)
- Billboard Music Awards: 11 pobjeda (Top Country Artist 7×, Top Female Country Artist 7×, Top Country Album 5×)
- CMT Music Awards: 24 pobjeda (Female Video of the Year 15×, Video of the Year 3×, Breakthrough Video 3×)
- Guinness World Records: Najviše CMA Female Vocalist pobjeda; jedini country umjetnik s 15 uzastopnih top-10 singlova.
Underwood-ova dosljednost kroz glasajuća tijela (industrija, fanovi, radio) podrazumijeva rijetku kombinaciju kritičkog prihvaćanja i komercijalne dominacije.